Forward Returns Following A US102 Year Inversion

A look at how markets have performed following a US 10-2 yield curve inversion.

Unless you’ve been living under a rock, you may have heard a thing or two about the yield curve inverting in the news recently. In fact, you probably heard the several months lead-up to its potential too. Well, the yield curve has indeed inverted and sparked a fresh round of calls for a recession some time over the next 20 or so months (although estimates do vary in the timing).

As my colleague Joe Perry pointed out, regardless of whether a session materialises, equites have tended to bounce after such a signal. So, we’ll start with backing this up with a chart and see how other markets reacted following an inverted 10-2 yr yield curve.

\

• Basically, an inverted yield curve has been positive for stocks overall
• Median prices (ie typically) trend higher between 0-3 months after the yield curve inverted
• Interestingly, on average the S&P500 was trading lower from 1-2 weeks out but, overall trends higher as it moves towards +3 months
• With exception to the next day, average returns were positive over 50% of time

• Somewhat surprisingly, WTI appears to show an even clearer trend than the S&P500
• Average returns are positive (and over 50% of the time) around the first week, and become increasingly more bullish from 1 to 3 months after the inversion
• It’s good to see average and median prices moving in lockstep, as it suggests the average returns are not powered by a few outliers

• Another surprise, this time from gold, where a trend is hard to decipher
• My expectations of a bullish trend have not been met
• With median prices negative one month after, with the average positive, there’s clearly some outliers here to push the average up
• Overall, gold’s pattern it too difficult to decipher to read much into it, surrounding inversions over this time horizon

• Taking a broader look at commodities (using the CRB Core Commodity Index) shows that, overall, commodities come under pressure
• That said, the trend is clearer on bearish average forward returns (outliers weigh it down) whilst median (ie typical) prices meander between bullish and bearish
• Whilst we could argue broad commodity prices are bearish on average, the trend is not as compelling as seen on S&P500 or WTI

• Copper prices tend to come under pressure for the month following the yield curve inversion
• Median prices remain bearish for up to 3-month, yet peak around 6 weeks after the signal
• Average returns are notable bullish 3 month out, although likely fueled by outliers as median remains bearish
• On average, forward returns are bearish over 50% of the time from T+3 onwards

• It appears that emerging markets (EEM EFT) love a good yield curve inversion.
• What’s compelling about this chart is how average and forward returns are clearly trending higher (and increasingly so towards +3 months) whilst also over 50% of the time (excluding the day of the signal
• However… it should also be noted that the technicals for EEM ETF do not currently align with this bullish view, so we’d urge to wait for a basing pattern to be confirmed before assuming a low might be in place
• And this data set is only form 2005 (so a smaller sample size means its statistical significance may be less reliable)

Related analysis:
Yield Curve Inverted…..So What?
The Fed Are Expected To Cut Today – How Has That Fared For Markets Historically?
GBP/USD Breaks Its 52-Week Low: Has That Provided An Edge In The Past?
US Indices Closed At New Highs: Do We Hold Or Fold?
Bitcoin: Do Volatile Bullish Sessions Lead To Further Gains?